MintDice Blog Post Image

How Crypto Governance Models Work

Until the advent of cryptocurrency in 2009, almost all businesses worked the same way. There were employees, managers watching those employees on a daily basis, and a board of directors overseeing the big picture. However, cryptocurrency set out to change the world, and it did so through a variety of governance models.

Governance models are the methods that blockchains use to make decisions without having a governing board as traditional businesses do. While there are a full range of options, most are based on proof of work, stake, or history. Read on to learn more about how crypto governance models work.

Pexels Ann Hannes 45017 38536528

Are All Crypto Governance Models the Same?

Before we dive in, it’s important to recognize that not all blockchains are created equal. While we aren’t here to convince you which is best, know that some are better than others—something we will leave you to decide. Just know that some are decentralized as intended, while others are not.  

It is also important to note that what constitutes as governance varies from site to site. In our eyes, consensus mechanisms are the meat of on-chain governance. Of course, there is also off-chain governance, but we won’t be covering much of that here since it usually mirrors the typical business governance we discussed above—which is a select few well-paid individuals making decisions for the entire company.

Proof-Of-Work

Proof-of-work is one of the earliest types of governance models, with those who can do the work being allowed to vote to make changes to the blockchain. The most notable example is Bitcoin, of course, which experienced a fork in 2017 as a result of a disagreement among those running the nodes about the future of the blockchain.

The important thing to remember about proof-of-work is that only those who are running nodes get to have a vote, which can price out smaller individuals, especially as mining grows more costly, as it has done in recent years. It also consumes a lot of energy, something that is a recurring point of contention when it comes to blockchain technology. This doesn’t make it bad, just something to note.

In proof of work, if a consensus can’t be reached, a fork will typically occur, as certain nodes will go rogue or against the agreement that was eventually reached. This makes them more likely to experience forks than other consensus mechanisms.

Proof-Of-Stake

Because of the rising concerns about energy costs for proof-of-work blockchains, many, most notably Ethereum, have switched to proof-of-stake. This consensus mechanism is different than Bitcoin in that it is all based on what percentage of the blockchain’s entire liquidity you own.

Unlike Bitcoin, it is notably cheaper to run; however, as you can probably guess, those who are the wealthiest still tend to hold the most control over the voting on the future of the blockchain. While Ethereum is a bit of a white buffalo because the creator is still around and actively pushing the blockchain forward, proof-of-stake blockchains can also be subject to shady behavior to try and sway voting one way or another. They are also often the subject of hacks because the algorithms used to maintain the consensus mechanism are far more varied and easier to game than those used for proof of work.

Pexels Pixabay 163064

Proof-Of-History

Made famous by the Solana blockchain, the creator took governance to a whole new level when he based future decisions of the blockchain based on blockchain history. While this is a great governance method for stopping double spend and it relies heavily on a ledger, it doesn’t really add governance in the same way the previous ones we mentioned do. In fact, proof of history is most often combined with centralized methods of governance, such as an appointed board to make future decisions for the blockchain.

While there are many downsides to proof-of-history, it does have some upsides as well. For one, it’s fast and cheap, making blockchain more accessible to the general masses. However, much of this speed comes from skipping the consensus stage—as the nodes automatically check blockchain history before moving forward with a transaction. As we said in the beginning, it isn’t necessarily bad, but it has a much different feel to it for those who are unfamiliar.

Proof-Of-Authority

Proof-of-authority is a consensus mechanism used by several blockchains, and it gives individual nodes the right to vote on changes to the blockchain based on pre-established approval. While it is fast and efficient, it is not anonymous and is therefore the consensus mechanism that is closest to traditional business structures.

Blockchains that use proof of authority are generally centralized, though they tend to stay small because more nodes would have to be verified to support growth. The most famous blockchain that uses this consensus mechanism is BNB Smart Chain.

Proof-Of-Capacity

Now we are delving into some of the more uncommon consensus mechanisms, as the ones we mentioned above are the most common and most likely to be those running your blockchain of preference. But we did want to mention proof-of-capacity, as it is around in some of the oldest renditions of consensus mechanisms, as it relies solely on nodes that are able to prove they have space for the ledger, meaning those that have more space are prioritized.

As you can imagine, this gets sticky as the blockchain grows, because fewer and fewer nodes have space for the rapidly growing ledger. It also encourages new joiners, which isn’t always the safest.

That being said, proof of capacity served the community for many years and can’t be all that bad if it is still around.

Overall, the consensus or governance method you prefer will vary based on what you are looking for in a blockchain. Just know that the consensus mechanism is where the conversation about governance starts, and it shouldn’t be used on its own to choose a blockchain for work, transfers, or wealth storage. You should become familiar with all aspects of a blockchain before trusting it, and the consensus mechanism is only a small part of that process.  

Crupto governance | Consensus | Consensus mechanisms | Proof of work | Proof of stake

Check out our games!

Wager cryptos with our provably fair casino games!